I
do believe that Diplomatic Risk was very realistic in many ways, especially in comparison
to the original game of Risk, but obviously also had its unrealistic aspects as
well. The game was realistic because every
team had different objectives, just as all countries around the world do in
terms of international policies and agendas.
In the regular game of risk, all countries have the same objective of
world domination, and in the real world a majority of countries do not actively
seek to accomplish this goal, even during times of war. Therefore, the twist on the original game
helped make it more realistic and comparable to real world politics. The game was unrealistic in some ways as
well. Alliances, neutrality, and wars do
not occur so quickly between states, and are much harder to break in real life
than in the game. Each team was so quick
to form alliances and declare war against other teams in order to gain that
they needed, and war was the main way to gain territory, though negotiating
existed. In world politics today, negotiations
are the main way in which actions and alliances form, not through physical
war. In this way, Diplomatic Risk was
much more parallel to world politics pre-WWII.
If
the game were to be changed in order to mirror world politics better, I think
one of the main things that would have to be established are military ranks for
power. In the game as it is, everyone is
on the same level playing field in terms of how powerful their armies may be,
and in reality, if the United States needed to infiltrate a territory that had
more military power than what they may have had, they would still be victorious
because of the other factors that go into war as well, such as nuclear weapons. Also, although this could be difficult in a
game such as Risk, to make the game more realistic to how world politics are
today, there would have to be an economic aspect to the game as well. In the game, there is the ability to trade
territories and such, but world trade has a very large role in world politics
today and is underrepresented in the game.
No comments:
Post a Comment